Metallica Albums Ranked and Rated
I found the average album ratings by rating each song from every album. Of course, this is just my opinion.
Master of Puppets: 9.63
...And Justice for All: 9.33
Ride the Lightning: 9.31
Kill 'Em All: 9.00
Metallica: 8.92
Death Magnetic: 8.80
Load: 8.68
72 Seasons: 8.67
Hardwired... to Self-Destruct: 8.50
Reload: 8.27
St. Anger: 7.82