What I would think of each gen 3 character winning in a sequel season

Beardo- maybe, I could see his story of overcoming his shyness could possibly propel him to the merge, but I'm not sure about the finale per se

Leonard- even if they do that story about him realizing that he's good and more than just LARPing I doubt that story would have enough meat to it to bring him to the merge, let alone the finale

Amy- heck no, once again a world where Amy outranks Sammy shouldn't be a thing that's allowed to exist

Rodney- similar to Beardo, there are ways for him to factor into the plot, but I could see him making the merge but not too sure about the finale

Sammy- if they play their cards right maybe, she could have a similar story to Beth, although Sammy's victory works better for a debut season in my opinion (I read a fic where she won and they made her a convincing finalist so...)

Ella- once again she could be a believable winner if they play their cards right. Pi felt like it was building her up to have this story where she realizes that the world isn't always perfect but she can still choose to be a good person despite it, but they just didn't do that, if they do that story with her maybe I could see her winning

Topher- probably not. I could see a small storyline where he realizes the kind of person Chris is and no longer admires him, or an episode where he takes the role of host by force, but I doubt either of those could make it out of the pre merge

Dave- possibly, if they give him the redemption arc he clearly needs (I'll never believe otherwise) he could have a world tour Heather style victory

Scarlett- once again the biggest wildcard of the cast. I could see several outcomes for her, including but not limited to, being the first boot as everyone would probably be terrified of her, feigning redemption but secretly still being evil, or getting redeemed for real. If they go with that last one maybe she could also have a wt Heather style victory

Max- don't see it. He's good for some more comedy but unless they're going to completely rehash his story with Scarlett I doubt he'd make it as far as he did previously

Jasmine- this is gonna be a hot take but I don't think Jasmine would be a convincing finalist. Her story with Shawn is completed and we don't need to fix what isn't broken. I suppose they could focus on her friendship with Sammy, but the only way I could see her getting as far as she did previously is completely reducing her role to just Sammy's best friend. Also she's the strongest contestant by a long shot, if she made the finale, no one could believably beat her

Sugar- hahaha no. Ella needs to outrank her, their rivalry is the second worst example in the series of the victim never outranking their bully (I'm sure we all know who the worst example is)

Sky- besides the fact that she was already a finalist, her character just doesn't have enough substance to make it that far a second time. Unless you want them to really drag out the Skave conflict a second time it's not gonna pan out

Shawn- besides already being a finalist, his story is completed. He really doesn't have enough material left to make it that far a second time