What brawling BB to buy?

I'm planning to get myself a mid-tier BB (so like Tier 7) for brawling. I'm stuck between dropping the coal right now for Scharnhorst 43, but then I heard some good things about Lugdunum's secondaries as well, so I'm also considering getting the next pass.

West Virginia 44 also isn't off the table, but being as fast as a 90 year old man with arthritis makes me doubt I can close the range easily.

Please let me know what y'all recommend, and why.