First time airgun buyer help

Hello looking for my first airgun. I’m desperate for an answer and can’t find anything beside GAMO which I’ve heard is awful

Budget:250-350

Preference: break barrel with a magazine

Usage:Plinking and small game rabbits and squirrels at 50-75 yards

Location:Indiana (USA)

Experience: 0 years experience I’ve shot 22lr but looking for something quieter