Vedic astrology or western astrology?

This is not a question to create competition between the two, only general curiosity.

Recently, I did readings for many of my friends using their Western charts, but none of the interpretations resonated with them. Then, I pulled up their Vedic charts, where the only difference was that the zodiac signs or planets had shifted one house forward or backward.

When I read their Vedic charts, everything made perfect sense to them. For example, in the Western chart, my friend’s North Node was in the eighth house, but nothing about that placement aligned with her life. In the Vedic chart, it shifted to the ninth house—representing travel, spirituality, and studies—which are the core of her life purpose and exactly what she lives for.

Doesn’t this suggest that Western charts might not always be entirely accurate?