Help

So I'm playing Sally face and ive done the super natural stuff with the game boy and now Todd is talking about the Mrs Sanderson murder and then sal says "okay, I'm going to keep searching for more supernatural stuff in the meantime" and I just don't rlly know what to do cause I did the supernatural stuff and I don't know where to keep looking and I just keep walking around with the gear boy and doing nothing😕(ep 2)